GALLATIN, Tenn. (WTVF) — The attorneys for the Gallatin Center for Rehabilitation and Healing officially rested their case Friday, meaning by Monday morning, closing arguments in the three-week trial should begin.
The final testimony featured expert witnesses, put on by the nursing home, that argued masking and health screenings can only do so much during a pandemic.
"If universal masking was in place prior to this outbreak having occurred, I would expect that on average, about 40% fewer staff or residents may have become infected, but just marginally less. Not prevented," testified Dr. Scott Fridkin, an infectious disease expert from Emory University.
Of course, attorneys for the family of Ruth Summers disagree. They're suing the Gallatin Center after the 89 year old contracted COVID and later died back during the early days of the pandemic. Dr. Fridkin testified COVID entering the facility was likely inevitable.
"Even if the screening was done perfectly, that virus would have been imported into the nursing home. And transmission would have occurred," said Fridkin.
"Was it inevitable?" asked Howard Hayden, an attorney for the nursing home.
"I do think it was inevitable at that time early in the pandemic. Almost no nursing homes were spared," he said.
Ultimately, this case will come down to this central question: Did the nursing home fail to properly protect Summers from COVID-19 or was the virus an inevitability?
Closing arguments and jury instructions will take place on Monday, and then 12 men and women of the jury will deliberate and make their final determination.
Do you have more information about this story? You can email me at Chris.Davis@NewsChannel5.com.
For people of my generation, in our younger days we spent part of our weekends watching music shows like American Bandstand and Soul Train. That was before the age of music videos. Several years before Soul Train was syndicated out of Chicago, another syndicated R&B show was taped in Nashville at NewsChannel 5. Night Train aired in the 60s and included what may have been the first TV appearance for legendary guitarist Jimi Hendrix. Forrest Sanders has another great look back at station history.
-Lelan Statom
