MoneyConsumerConsumer Reports

Actions

Should you buy rental car insurance? Consumer Reports experts dive in.

Posted
and last updated

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WTVF) — The next time you rent a car, you’ll likely get the same question as the last time: Should you buy rental car insurance? You might think your credit card or auto insurance covers you, but that’s not the whole story.

Sean Beasley spends a lot of time on the road.

“I would say I rent a car probably about 20 times a year,” said Beasley.

As for insurance for all those rentals, he says he’s covered.

“I don't get insurance because my insurer, my vehicle insurer, automatically offers us rental car insurance,” he added.

He says he pays his insurer a monthly fee for the “rental coverage” included with his policy.

“Both auto insurance and credit cards can have significant limitations regarding rental cars, including what kinds of vehicles they cover, for how long, and in what countries,” said Consumer Reports' Lisa Gill.

Rental car insurance can be expensive, sometimes an extra 50 bucks per day. When does adding it to the rental make sense?

“If you only have liability insurance on your own car, you’ll need to get a separate policy for the car rental in case there’s damage to it in the event of a crash,” Gill said.

Here are some guidelines to help you decide if extra coverage is right for you

  • Is the rental car fancier than your car? Some credit card rental insurance and personal auto policies won’t cover certain car types or classes, like large sport utility vehicles or luxury cars.
  • Are you renting in a foreign country? Allstate, Geico, Farmers, State Farm and Progressive say that your auto insurance coverage extends only to car rentals in the U.S. and Canada. The same goes for rental insurance offered by most credit card companies.
  • Finally, if you’re renting an RV, a cargo van, or a moving truck, these vehicles are usually not covered under standard auto or credit card insurance policies.

    And if you decide to add extra insurance, consider adding up to three types –

  • Collision Damage Waiver, which covers damage to the car in case of a wreck.
  • Loss Damage Waiver, which protects you from theft and damage to the car.
  • And Liability Coverage covers you if you are found legally responsible property damage or for injuring someone while driving the rental.

Terms might be slightly different depending on the rental car agency.
If you’re renting a car for work, check with your employer to understand what’s covered and what’s not since your personal insurance and credit cards likely won’t provide any insurance for these types of rentals.

Do you have more information about this story? You can email me at jennifer.kraus@newschannel5.com.

Remembering Eudora Boxley, a trailblazing TV cook from WLAC's early days

Forrest Sanders recently introduced us to a Nashville hero named Eudora Boxley. She was the first black woman to have a cooking show on TV in Nashville. Her grandson was precious describing Eudora and how she raised him and how proud he and the family were of her impact not only on WLAC but on a city during the turbulent Civil Rights Era. A woman who did extraordinary things at a time when history did not expect her to.

-Amy Watson